Le Skunk
Low Sec Liberators
   |
Posted - 2009.03.11 21:37:00 -
[1]
Edited by: Le Skunk on 11/03/2009 21:38:04
 Originally by: Bish Ounen
1) Wardecs have an "Initial" and "Continuing" state.
 Sounds Fine
Originally by: Bish Ounen
This encourages people to NOT continuously wardec one corp until they are dead, but to stick to short-term wardecs.
Bad. This would devalue the whole point of war deccing someone. Short Term Wardecs are not in themselves a good thing. If you go to war with someone, it should be with the intention of defeating the enemy, righting a wrong, getting compensation etc - which wont happen if the enemy just has to go quiet for a week or so. With no threat of a perma dec - there is no reason to capitulate... or even fight back
Originally by: Bish Ounen
3) To prevent "corp hopping" no-one may leave a wardecced corp for the full duration of an "Initial" wardec.
Good idea. However, I would circumvent this by wardecing your corp with different alt corps - thus ensuring the war is always in "initial" phase - trapping your members in your corp for ever
Originally by: Bish Ounen
4) To prevent "Alliance hopping" a corp MAY NOT join an alliance after an "Initial" wardec has started, but MAY join an alliance once the "Initial" period is over, whether the wardec ends or goes into "continuing" mode.
1) Alliance hopping is actualy mainly when a corp DROPS from an alliance to avoid a wardec, not joins an alliance. This would not be affected,
2)I will stop your corp ever joining any alliance EVER by deccing it multiple times with diferent corps.
Originally by: Bish Ounen
5) A corp already in the process of joining an alliance is protected from any NEW wardecs during the changeover period, to prevent confusion and other problems.
Couldnt hurt afaics.
Originally by: Bish Ounen
6) a "Wardec Balance" system will be put in place wherein the "target" corp/alliance may not be more than 50% smaller AND 50% younger or 50% less experienced than the wardeccing corp/alliance. this is to prevent large and/or highly experienced and/or high skill level players from easily picking on very young or very small corporations with very young and inexperienced players.
So a small, new corp can can flip, insult, bump, steal resources, upset markets for an older corp without fear of a wardec.
No thanks
Also I can just about see some bodges where i could stick two noob alts in my corp and thus tip the balance into making it undecable.
------
Basically, whilst I applaud you for spending time thinking on this issue - your proposals are almost as full of flaws as the present system.
This is nothing to be embarrassed about - CCP have a staff of "experts" who cannot fix the issue - instead implementing the farcical "alliance P" nerfs then ignoring all the subsequent abuses (which i will note I was among many to warn them would be the result of their actions)
SKUNK
(o)
|